Tuesday, May 03, 2016


Forbidden Mixtures

by Reb Gutman Locks   


    In this week's Torah portion,[ii] many commandments are given. Some, such as not to commit perversions in weights and measures, are quite logical. Obviously, it is wrong to cheat in business. But some of the laws listed in this portion are apparently so illogical that they defy man's ability to understand them. In fact, the sages tell us that this type of law (called a "chok") has no logical reason.

     The most commonly singled out law for its complete "illogic" is the law dealing with forbidden mixtures. There are four basic types of forbidden mixtures: mixture of seeds (when planting plants), mixture of orchids (fruit trees), mixtures in species (when breeding animals), and mixture of linen and flax (in our garments). The Torah warns us that such mixtures sap the strength from the individual species.

    What could these laws possibly be teaching us today?

    Here the Torah is using a common Talmudic principle called "all the more so" (kal v'chomer).

   When we look, we see that each of these forbidden mixtures points back to us. For instance:

 --The seeds of a garden are like a man's own seed.

 --The fruit of a tree is its offspring. A man is likened to a tree of the field and, fittingly, our children are called our fruit.

 --Our animals are not merely our physical animals but also our spiritual animals, our animal inclinations.

 --And our garments are our deeds.

    Now to apply the "all the more so" principle: If I am not to mix my vegetable seeds because this will drain the strength of each plant, and if I am not to mix my fruit trees as this will weaken the fruit of my trees, and if I am not to mix my animals as this will produce weakened livestock, and if I am not to mix my garments that are also my deeds, then surely all the more so, I am not to mix my actual offspring—my children, my family.

    Jews are commanded to marry only Jews and raise Jewish families to maintain a healthy, vibrant, Jewish people in the world. Without doubt, this is the greatest test facing the Jewish nation today, as the vast majority of Jews around the world intermarry.


[i] First published in; "From the Old City" - Gutman's book on the weekly Torah portions

[ii] Kedoshim


  1. I, on the other hand, see this law as extremely 'LOGICAL'. I see it as intellectually and morally logical. Even the laws (chukim) that we cannot understand, such as the parah adumah, makes sense to me (as far, of course, as I can comprehend) because H' demands it and He is our Creator and whatever is written in our Torah is Perfect and always makes pure moral sense! Those who are always at war with the Ribbono Shel Olam will find fault with the most common sense thing, only because H' commanded it and mostly, it is always morally correct.

  2. A Jew is the offspring of a Jewish mother. Sinful or not, intermarriage doesn't seem to necessarily and ostensibly diminish the number of Jewish births overall - especially nowadays when it must account for a majority or significant minority of Jewish births.

  3. Anon @12:22 AM - Intermarriage is the greatest scourge on the Jewish people. When the Reform movement actually condones and accepts children with Jewish fathers and non-Jewish mothers as Jewish. With so many assimilated, unaffilated Jews who know practically nothing of Judaism, all it does is create a horror where every 'caring' Jew will have to have a geneaological research done on potential mates. With today's thinking, we have created a living nightmare.

  4. Nowadays, there are several marriages where the woman is fully Jewish, ie both mother and father Jewish, but the man where just the father is Jewish. No-one blinks an eyelid.


Welcome to Mystical Paths comments. Have your say here, but please keep the tone reasonably civil and avoid lashon hara. Due to past commenting problems, all comments are moderated (this may take a few hours.)

Your comments are governed by our Terms of Use, Privacy, and Comments policies. We reserve the right to delete or edit your comments for any reason, or use them in a future article. That said, YOU are responsible for YOUR comments - not us.

Related Posts with Thumbnails