Friday, August 06, 2010

// // 1 comment

Why The Rubashkin Case is So Troubling

Commentary by Reb Akiva @ Mystical Paths

It took me some time to realize why I find the Rubashkin case so troubling. 

For those who don’t know about this case, the head of the largest kosher meat processing company in the US was arrested during an immigration raid on his factory in Iowa.  Hundreds of illegal aliens were found to be working at the factory.  With the removal of most of the employees, the company cash flow stopped, it defaulted on bank loans and went bankrupt.  The government said they were going to charge the CEO with knowingly hiring illegal aliens, 500 charges of such.  After a lengthy investigation, only the CEO was charged and he was charged with…bank fraud for false statements on a company loan application that the company defaulted on after being shut down by the raid – for which he was convicted and sentenced to 20 years in prison, and with underage workers (some of the illegal aliens were 17 years old) – for which he was acquitted.

Some bloggers were all over Mr. Rubashkin. He broke the law now he has to do the time.  But what law? 

While the videos above are very long, they point out that the current legal code in the United States (and many other Western nations) is such that you’re almost guaranteed to break the law every day.  The officer in the video says “I can follow you for 15 minutes in the car and guaranteed I’ll be able to pull you over for some infraction.”

What may appear to you to be perfectly normal banking transactions, a pretty average tax return, normal business practices, normal charity practices, any and all of them may violate some obscure provision of the legal code and put you at risk for years in jail.

So the government comes to Agriprocessors, Aron’s Best Kosher, and raids the plant for illegal aliens.  They investigate and find, oh look, the illegal aliens actually presented pretty realistic papers to show a right to work, so they can’t successfully prosecute anyone for hiring them.  So they go fishing for additional crimes…to justify the raid and putting a company out of business.  Hmm, child labor?  They try that but fail, same documentation problem.  Well, we’ve got banks screaming because the company just defaulted on a $30 million dollar loan (because their employees were carted away and the management arrested, so they can’t try to hire replacements or make decisions). 

So they spend 6 months with a team of forensic accountants to go through every line of the company’s books, every payment, every invoice, every paper submitted to the IRS, every paper submitted to the bank.

And they find something!  A few invoices overstate the actual product amount – inflated invoices.  Why?  We don’t know.  A business friend giving a loan in a quiet way?  Hiding some money movement from the IRS?  They can’t determine any of these things and can’t charge on it.

BUT, two of these invoices were used on a bank loan application to show company average business.  A factual error on a paper submitted for a loan which wasn’t paid back is bank fraud.  They got him!

Except the reason he couldn’t pay it back was because the company was shut down by an immigration raid (for which nobody was charged with a crime) and for which he was put in prison (though there was no crime with which he was charged at the time) and therefore couldn’t manage the situation.  Of course you can’t quickly hire 500 people, nor get bank credit when you are under investigation and house arrest.

So the company shuts down and can’t pay back the loan…which the government is waiting for to be able to prosecute him.

It’s an interesting thought experiment actually…if he refused to hire Hispanics unless they had extensive paperwork and spoke English, he’d be accused of discrimination and have the ACLU or the EEOE all over him.

Net net he made some mistakes and may not have been a good business manager.  But when the government targets you, almost anyone is going down.  And when the justice system has become such that you’re relying on the prosecutors to “be reasonable”, it’s no longer just.

Oh, and it came out yesterday the judge broke judicial procedure as he consulted on the raid beforehand and therefore couldn’t (but did) judge the case he helped set up.

1 comment:

  1. My wife and I spent 286+ days jumping through the necessary hoops in her country and mine in order to get her to the States legally. I have ZERO tolerance for illegals!

    Yes, I can understand the temptation to hire Mexican illegals. They do the work that most whites and blacks in the States don't want to do.

    That said, I don't doubt that many employers haven't a clue if they're hiring illegals or not!

    The illegals know how to use "the System" and acquire fake IDs and bogus social security numbers and lie about anything and everything in order to get the jobs most of us legal citizens don't want do - whether the job itself pays well or not.

    We Americans have been socially engineered into becoming a fat, lazy breed of hot house roses with an over inflated sense of entitlement, a fast-food mentality and an Ego that's totally given over to satisfying the constant cry of "ME! ME! ME!" that comes from pampering our individual and collective Evil Impulse.

    With most of the factories having moved to China and the Big Boys having destroyed all the Mom & Pop stores and the "dirty jobs" going to illegals and Asians that have a superior work ethic than most white and black Americans, is it any wonder that our country continues to be economically and morally collapsed?

    Our fate has been sealed and our total destruction is only a matter of time. This daughter of Imperial Rome will fall and fall hard!

    Social Security is now in the red and I'm suppose to believe the lie that it'll improve when the economy rebounds? LOL! Even if I live that long, I'll never see a dime of Social Security - not to mention my 401K or Mutal Funds! That'll be dust in the wind!

    The Powers-That-Be, like all slave owners, LOVE their illegals! And keeping the "pro-illegal cutlure" going just helps to speed our ultimate collapse and it paves the way for EXTREME MEASURES in the future.

    HOWEVER, when these Elites see a chance to take down a Jewish businessman, especially a religious one, they won't hesitate to set aside their "pro-illegal agenda" in order to play "kick the Jew!" That's just the nature of this horrible beast! Rubashkin was railroaded, may HaShem set him free and give him the wisdom to leave America and move to Israel!

    And all that talk about "border security"...? That's not to keep the illegals OUT! That's to keep the Americans IN! If I had the means and wherewithal to leave this pathetic country and the birthright to move elsewhere ... I'd be gone tomorrow!


Welcome to Mystical Paths comments. Have your say here, but please keep the tone reasonably civil and avoid lashon hara.

Your comments are governed by our Terms of Use, Privacy, and Comments policies. We reserve the right to delete or edit your comments for any reason, or use them in a future article. That said, YOU are responsible for YOUR comments - not us.

Related Posts with Thumbnails