Sunday, September 06, 2009

// // Leave a Comment

Dogma Demonstrated

In reply to your email reply to me asking for a blog link...

I read your reply. You are gravely mistaken. You do not understand torah, nor science. You just believe what you read in the newspapers and textbooks. Listen to Rabbi Avigdor Miller tapes for a year and maybe you will be able to do tshuvah.

Rabbi (censored for privacy)

Kovod l'Rav,

One of the definitions of the dogmatic approach of religions such as Xianity is an unwavering belief without foundation, questioning, argument, or explanation of any kind. I am surprised a rav of your caliber would use methods of another religion.

You did not respond to my arguments. You did not bring quotes from the Torah, Mishnah, Gemorah, Mishneh Torah, Tur, Shulchan Aruch, Shulchan Aruch HaRav, Aruch HaShulchan, or Mishneh Brura. You did not demonstrate a single Torah support for your position.

Your blog makes bold statements against much of the Jewish people, and attacks those who raise legitimate questions and issues that need attention in the context of our time. Further, it does it with no presented foundation or basis.

If your positions have merit according to the Torah, prove it the Torah way! If you would be zealous for Hashem, be sure your heart is pure, your hands are clear, and there is no joy in what you are doing.

Respectfully, this is an argument for the sake of Torah. B'ahavat yisroel, and wishes for you, your family and all of klal yisroel to have a kesivah v'chatima tova.

0 comments:

Related Posts with Thumbnails