Wednesday, April 29, 2009


Israeli Independence Day

by Reb Akiva at Mystical Paths

Israeli Independence Day is an odd time for an American Jew in Israel...

. Very patriotic, flags everywhere. Music, celebrations, events throughout the country. We're not used to this in-the-face appreciation of State. Of course, we're also not used to neighbor States that want to kill us, and try now and again.

. STRANGE religious positions associated with this secular state holiday. Those positions are...

--- Ultra-secular, where the State celebration is a replacement religious event to hang in front of those segments of the population who aren't secular.

--- National-religious, where the State celebration has relgio-messianic overtones as the first major step of the geulah, and an invested kedushah (holiness) from Hashem in re-settling the Land and re-engaging as a people as an active Nation (State) of G-d. For this segment, the day is a religious celebration on par with Purim and Chanukah, with special prayers in synogogue including Hallel (the prayers of great praise).

--- Average Charedi (ultra-orthodox), where the State of Israel would be just another secular government to be lived within, if it weren't for periodic government anti-religious actions which require communal opposition. The average charedi tries to straddle the strange line of not pissing off the ultra-secular by ignoring certain unavoidable holiday traditions, but not investing the day in any special or (G-d forbid) religious meaning - particularly given past Gedolim's statements that this secular zionist path is not a positive one for the Jewish people and the Land of Israel.

--- Extreme Charedi, where the State of Israel is a negative thing, one who's influences and actions are always suspect and frequently understood to be antithetical to the Jewish religious way of life. The extreme charedi is tearing flags of buses passing through his neighborhood, and may be attending an anti-State protest on Independence Day.

A video of local celebrations, including live music.


  1. Akiva, "Average Haredi ...not pissing off". So glad you are human. :-)

    For me, It's a great day for me. My wifes family who are native Israelis make this day one to be very proud of. I feel the same way and hope one day that the real deal comes our way. Until then Chag Sameach.

  2. FYI, it's not as patriotic as you think. The gov't of Israel forces the Israelis to close the schools, stores, markets, etc. even buses! If they don't close on this day, their license is taken away FOREVER. It's communism, not patriotic!

  3. Akiva, you and your family are not Americans anymore! You once lived in the US but that's not your heritage. A loooooooong time ago, you were here, in Eretz HaKodesh, at Mt Sinai. Don't you remember!

    You should remember EVERY DAY, not just on Israeli Independence Day.

  4. Umm..."Neshoma"...Har Sinai is not and was not in Eretz Yisrael.

    May the horrid "State" speedily decompose and give way to Mashiach amen.

  5. to anonymous: I left out the "AND". You're soooooooooooooooooo observant! :-)

  6. the state is sick BUT its a haven for jews . I wished to destroy as a people your vine is of sodom except for the long haired skull of the gentile warrior who said its my might , ie like titus , thats done this to God / israel . Lets be all a litle humble here only moshe rabbeinu was at the top of sinai when i checked the bible last . Ahavat yisrael and try to know there is bad in the good of the haredi and good in the bad of the secular


Welcome to Mystical Paths comments. Have your say here, but please keep the tone reasonably civil and avoid lashon hara.

Your comments are governed by our Terms of Use, Privacy, and Comments policies. We reserve the right to delete or edit your comments for any reason, or use them in a future article. That said, YOU are responsible for YOUR comments - not us.

Related Posts with Thumbnails